目的 比较托吡酯与氟哌啶醇治疗儿童抽动障碍的疗效及安全性,为临床治疗提供参考依据。方法 计算机检索PubMed、EBSCO、EMbase、Ovid、Cochrane Library、中国期刊全文数据库、万方数据库和维普中文科技期刊数据库,纳入关于托吡酯与氟哌啶醇治疗儿童抽动障碍的随机对照研究,检索时限从建库起至2014年1月,手工检索相关的已发表文献。由两位研究者独立进行文献筛检、资料提取和方法学质量评价后,采用Revman5.1和Stata12.0软件进行Meta分析。结果 最终纳入16篇RCTs,共1 148例患者(治疗组609例;对照组539例),年龄2.5~17岁。Meta分析结果显示,两组抽动症状改善的总例数差异有统计学意义[OR=1.71,(95%CI:1.22~2.39)];两组运动性抽动分数、发声性抽动分数、综合损害分数和严重度总分差异均有统计学意义[MD -13.58~-4.58(95%CI:-22.44~-1.32),P均<0.01];两组不良反应发生总例数差异有统计学意义[OR=0.42,(95%CI:0.24~0.75)]。结论 托吡酯用于治疗儿童抽动障碍尤其是抽动秽语综合症,其疗效及安全性均优于氟哌啶醇。
Abstract
Objective To assess the efficacy and safety of Topiramate and Haloperidol in the treatment of children with tic disorder. Methods The randomized controlled trials about children with tic disorder treated with Topiramate and Haloperidol published before January 2014,were searched in the PubMed,EBSCO,EMbase,Ovid,Cochrane Library,CNKI,Wanfang Date and VIP.Some published references were hand-searched.Two reviewers independently screened the literatures,extracted the data and evaluated quality.Meta analysis was conducted by Revman 5.1 and Stata 12.0 software. Results Sixteen RCTs involving 1 148 patients [treatment group (n=609);control group (n=539)] were included.Ages were 2.5 to 17 years old.Meta-analysis of motor tic scores,vocal tic scores,comprehensive damage scores and severity scores indicated the treatment group was superior to the control group [Mean difference (Inverse Variance,Random) -13.58 to -4.58 (95%CI:-22.44~-1.32)].Meta-analysis of the number of tic symptom improvement showed the treatment group was superior to the control group (OR=1.71,95%CI:1.22~2.39).Meta-analysis of the number of adverse events showed the treatment group was superior to the control group(OR=0.42,95%CI:0.24~0.75). Conclusion Topiramate has more advantage than haloperidol in the efficacy and safety for children with tic disorder,especially Tourette syndrome.
关键词
托吡酯 /
氟哌啶醇 /
儿童 /
抽动障碍 /
Meta分析
Key words
Topiramate /
Haloperidol /
children /
tic disorder /
Meta-analysis
{{custom_sec.title}}
{{custom_sec.title}}
{{custom_sec.content}}
参考文献
[1] 张剑英,周江文,潘金贤.妥泰与氟哌啶醇治疗多发性抽动症疗效及安全性分析[J].温州医学院学报,2006,36(3):269-270.
[2] 陶荣辉,陈云英.托吡酯对儿童抽动障碍的疗效及对患儿血浆谷氨酸和门冬氨酸水平的影响[J].儿科药学杂志,2013,19(6):21-23.
[3] Du JC,Chiu TF,Lee KM,et al.Tourette syndrome in children:an updated review[J].Pediatrics & Neonatology,2010,51(5):255-264.
[4] Kim YH,Son CG,Ku BC,et al.Herbal medicines for treating tic disorders:a systematic review of randomized controlled trials[J].Chinese Medicine,2014,9(1):6-12.
[5] 甘汝红.托吡酯治疗儿童多发性抽动症的临床观察[J].黑龙江医学,2012,36(6):458-460.
[6] 王桂兰,李明丽,陈冰.托吡酯治疗儿童抽动障碍的临床研究[J].天津药学,2008,20(6):52-53.
[7] 刘文新,郭青云.妥泰治疗儿童多发性抽动症效果观察[J].右江民族医学院学报,2006,28(3):432-433.
[8] 梁国安,姚桂飞.妥泰治疗儿童多发性抽动症的疗效观察[J].实用医学杂志,2010,26(22):4192-2193.
[9] Jankovic J,Jimenez-Shahed J,Brown LW.A randomized,double-blind,placebo-controlled study of topiramate in the treatment of Tourette syndrome[J].Journal of Neurology,Neurosurgery & Psychiatry,2010,81(1):70-73.
[10] Yang CS,Zhang LL,Zeng LN,et al.Topiramate for Tourette's Syndrome in children:A Meta-analysis[J].Pediatric Neurology,2013,49(5):344-350.
[11] 李金水.托吡酯治疗儿童抽动障碍疗效评价[J].海峡药学,2008,20(12):114-115.
[12] 陈华芳,张平.妥泰治疗儿童多发性抽动障碍治疗价值评价[J].中外健康文摘,2009,6(26):55-56.
[13] 朱兰平,于荣静.小剂量托吡酯治疗小儿Tourette综合征疗效的初步观察[J].黑龙江医学,2011,35(10):766-768.
[14] 林郁生,林广裕,林洁英,等.托吡酯与氟哌啶醇治疗Tourette综合征临床对照观察[J].新乡医学院学报,2004,21(5):351-353.
[15] 王晓.妥泰在儿童多发性抽动症中的临床应用[J].中国儿童保健杂志,2004,12(5):414,422.
[16] 常健,赵红霞,李海波,等.托吡酯治疗儿童多发性抽动症疗效评估[J].中国妇幼保健,2006,21(9):1211-1213.
[17] 张金剑.托吡酯对抽动障碍患儿血清炎症因子水平的影响及疗效观察[J].药物流行病学杂志,2013,22(08):417-419.
[18] Kuo SH,Jimenez-Shahed J.Topiramate in treatment of Tourette syndrome[J].Clinical Neuropharmacology,2010,33(1):32-34.
[19] Higgins JPT,Green S.Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions[M/OL].The Cochrane Collaboration;2011.[2013-4-20]http://www.Cochrane-handbook.org (20,2013),2012.
[20] 黄先萍.妥泰治疗儿童多发性抽动症临床分析[J].西部医学,2007,19(2):261-262.
[21] 李爱菊.托吡酯治疗儿童抽动症疗效分析[J].中外医疗,2011,30(11):129-130.
[22] 肖农,王俐.妥泰治疗多发性抽动症临床研究[J].重庆医科大学学报,2004,29(4):531-533.
[23] 齐越,魏小维.多发性抽动症发病相关因素的研究进展[J].中国儿童保健杂志,2013,21(6):618-619.
[24] 王航雁,王静,安涛.妥吡酯治疗儿童抽动障碍的临床疗效观察[J].中国儿童保健杂志,2005,13(1):42-43.
[25] Abuzzahab FS,BROWN VL.Control of Tourette's syndrome with topiramate[J].American Journal of Psychiatry,2001,158(6):968-968.
基金
北京市科技计划课题(Z131100002613003);北京市科技计划课题(D101107047810004)
PDF(559 KB)
