不同康复疗法改善痉挛型脑瘫患儿运动功能障碍疗效的网状Meta分析

doi:10.11852/zgetbjzz2023-0585

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 目的系统评价水疗、康复机器人、核心稳定性训练(CST)、全身振动训练(WBV)、重复经颅磁刺激(rTMS)、悬吊训练(SET)、任务导向性训练(TOT)、虚拟现实(VR)8种康复疗法对痉挛型脑瘫患儿运动功能障碍的干预效果,为患儿康复方案的科学选择提供参考依据。方法计算机检索PubMed、The Cochrane Library、Web of Science、EmBase、CNKI、CBM、VIP和WanFang Data数据库,搜集有关8种康复疗法治疗痉挛型脑瘫患儿运动功能障碍的随机对照试验(RCTs),检索时限均为建库至2022年12月。由2名研究者独立进行文献筛选、数据提取及文献质量评价,采用 ADDIS 1.16.6软件进行网状Meta分析,采用 Stata 16.0 软件进行图形绘制。结果共纳入43项RCTs,包括2 722例痉挛型脑瘫患儿。网状 Meta 分析结果显示,在提高GMFM-88评分方面,WBV(MD=18.56,95%CI:34.91~2.45,P＜0.05)疗效最佳;在提高GMFM-88 D区评分方面,康复机器人疗效最佳(MD=6.30,95%CI:8.44~4.41,P＜0.05);在GMFM-88 E区评分方面,康复机器人疗效最佳(MD=10.03,95%CI:15.03~4.84,P＜0.05);在提高BBS评分方面,水疗疗效最佳(MD=11.24,95%CI:22.26~0.20,P＜0.05)。结论对于痉挛型脑瘫患儿,WBV是改善其粗大运动功能的最佳康复疗法,康复机器人是改善其站立和步行功能的最佳康复疗法,水疗是改善其平衡功能的最佳康复疗法。

关键词: 痉挛型脑瘫, 康复训练, 运动功能, 网状Meta分析, 随机对照试验

Abstract: Objective To systematically evaluate the effects of various rehabilitation therapies, including hydrotherapy, rehabilitation robot, core stability training (CST), whole-body vibration training (WBV), repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS), sling exercise training (SET), task-oriented training (TOT) and virtual reality (VR), on motor dysfunction in children with spastic cerebral palsy, so as to provide a reference for the scientific selection of rehabilitation programs for children. Methods Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of the 8 rehabilitation therapies in the treatment of motor dysfunction in children with spastic cerebral palsy were searched from various databases, including PubMed, The Cochrane Library, Web of Science, EmBase, CNKI, CBM, VIP, and WanFang Database, from database inception to December 2022. Two researchers independently conducted literature screening, data extraction, and literature quality evaluation. Network Meta-analysis was performed using ADDIS 1.16.6 software, and Stata 16.0 software was used for graphic representation. Results A total of 43 RCTs involving 2 722 children with spastic cerebral palsy were included in the analysis. The results of the network Meta-analysis indicated that WBV had the most significant effect in improving the GMFM-88 score (MD=18.56, 95%CI: 34.91 - 2.45, P＜0.05). Rehabilitation robot had the most significant effect in improving dimensions D (MD=6.30, 95%CI: 8.44 - 4.41, P＜0.05) and E (MD=10.03, 95%CI: 15.03 - 4.84, P＜0.05) of the GMFM-88 score. Additionally, hydrotherapy showed the most significant effect in improving the BBS score (MD=11.24, 95%CI: 22.26 - 0.20, P＜0.05). Conclusions For children with spastic cerebral palsy, WBV is the most effective rehabilitation therapy to improve gross motor function, rehabilitation robot is the most effective therapy for improving standing and walking function, and hydrotherapy is the most effective therapy for improving balance.

Key words: spastic cerebral palsy, rehabilitation training, motor function, network Meta-analysis, randomized controlled trials

中图分类号:

R742.3

宰伟仪, 徐宁, 吴伟, 王月莹. 不同康复疗法改善痉挛型脑瘫患儿运动功能障碍疗效的网状Meta分析[J]. 中国儿童保健杂志, 2024, 32(5): 543-551.

ZAI Weiyi, XU Ning, WU Wei, WANG Yueying. Network Meta-analysis of the effect of different rehabilitation therapies on improving motor dysfunction in children with spastic cerebral palsy[J]. Chinese Journal of Child Health Care, 2024, 32(5): 543-551.

参考文献

[1] Sadowska M,Sarecka-Hujar B,Kopyta I.Cerebral palsy:Current opinions on definition, epidemiology, risk factors, classification and treatment options[J].Neuropsychiatr Dis Treat,2020,16:1505-1518.
[2] Lin Y,Wang G,Wang B.Rehabilitation treatment of spastic cerebral palsy with radial extracorporeal shock wave therapy and rehabilitation therapy[J].Medicine (Baltimore),2018,97(51):e13828.
[3] Huang C,Chen Y,Chen G,et al.Efficacy and safety of core stability training on gait of children with cerebral palsy: A protocol for a systematic review and meta-analysis[J].Medicine (Baltimore),2020,99(2):e18609.
[4] 邓经辉,龙正印,吕志刚,等.核心稳定训练改善痉挛型脑瘫患儿运动能力的Meta分析[J].中国儿童保健杂志,2022,30(11):1226-1230.
Deng JH,Long ZY,Lyu ZG,et al.Meta-analysis on the effect of core stability training on the movement ability of children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Chin J Child Health Care,2022,30(11):1226-1230.(in Chinese)
[5] 尹宏伟,李海峰,张鑫,等.全身振动疗法对痉挛型双瘫患儿下肢运动功能的影响[J].中华物理医学与康复杂志,2019,41(10):5.
Yin HW,Li HF,Zhang X,et al.The effects of whole-body vibration therapy on lower extremity motor function in children with spastic diplegia[J].Chin J Phys Med and Rehabil,2019,41(10):5.(in Chinese)
[6] Mahgoub MSE,Younan WWA,Abd Elhakiem NM,et al.Effect of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in decreasing muscle tone of spastic hemiplegic children: A randomized controlled trial[J].Clin Schizophr Relat Psychoses,2021,15(5):1-6.
[7] 曲铭,林惠.核心肌群训练对 20 例痉挛型脑性瘫痪患儿下肢运动功能的疗效观察[J].中国中西医结合儿科学,2014,6(6):545-546.
Qu M,Lin H.Effect of core muscle training on lower limb motor function in 20 children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Chin Pediatr Integr Tradit West Med,2014,6(6):545-546.(in Chinese)
[8] 尚培民,李燕萍.核心稳定性训练对痉挛型脑性瘫痪患儿运动功能及步行能力的影响[J].中国中西医结合儿科学,2019,11(5):372-375.
Shang PM,Li YP.Effect of core stability training on motor function and walking ability in children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Chin Pediatr Integr Tradit West Med,2019,11(5):372-375.(in Chinese)
[9] 张正璇,赵泓垚.核心肌群训练引导康复在痉挛型脑瘫患儿中的应用[J].现代诊断与治疗,2021,32(6):965-966.
Zhang ZX,Zhao HY.Application of core muscle training guided rehabilitation in children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Mod Diagn Treat,2021,32(6):965-966.(in Chinese)
[10] 王永峰,李晓捷,吕洋,等.核心稳定性训练对痉挛型脑瘫患儿粗大运动功能及步行能力的影响[J].中国康复理论与实践,2012,18(4):350-353.
Wang YF,Li XJ,LYU Y,et al.Effects of core stability training on gross motor function and walking ability of children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Chin J Rehabil Theory Pract,2012,18(4):350-353.(in Chinese)
[11] 林国辉,俞梦瑾,叶瑞雄,等.核心稳定性训练在痉挛型脑瘫儿童康复运动中的运用与疗效观察[J].人人健康,2016,35(12):67-68.
Lin GH,Yu MJ,Ye RX,et al.Application and curative effect of core stability training in rehabilitation exercise of children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Health For Everyone,2016,35(12):67-68.(in Chinese)
[12] 田红转.核心稳定训练结合运动疗法对痉挛型脑瘫患儿粗大运动功能及行走能力的影响[J].齐齐哈尔医学院学报,2019,40(1):75-76.
Tian HZ.Effects of core stability training combined with exercise therapy on gross motor function and walking ability in children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].J Qiqihar Med Univ,2019,40(1):75-76.(in Chinese)
[13] 韩雪.对痉挛型脑瘫患儿进行核心稳定性训练的效果探讨[J].当代医药论丛,2019,17(20):78-79.
Han X.Study on the effect of core stability training for children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Contemporary Med Symposium,2019,17(20):78-79.(in Chinese)
[14] 罗文文.功能性水疗对痉挛型脑瘫儿童肌力及运动功能的影响分析[J].中国疗养医学,2018,27(9):909-911.
Luo WW.Effect of functional hydrotherapy on muscle strength and motor function in children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Chin J Convalescent Med,2018,27(9):909-911.(in Chinese)
[15] 朱青,吕露芬,门爽.水疗干预对痉挛型脑瘫患儿下肢运动技能水平的影响[J].青岛医药卫生,2022,54(3):202-204.
Zhu Q,LYU LF,Men S.Effect of hydrotherapy intervention on lower limb motor skills of children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Qingdao Med J,2022,54(3):202-204.(in Chinese)
[16] 邹育庭,张惠佳,汤孟平,等.水疗法配合 Bobath 法治疗痉挛型脑性瘫痪的临床观察[J].中国医师杂志,2014,16(9):3.
Zou YT,Zhang HJ,Tang MP,et al.Clinical observation on the treatment of spastic cerebral palsy by hydrotherapy and Bobath[J].J Chin Physician,2014,16(9):3.(in Chinese)
[17] 叶楠,樊启红,陈治江,等.下肢机器人辅助步态训练对脑性瘫痪患儿康复效果及生活质量的影响研究[J].中国医学装备,2020,17(11):94-97.
Ye N,Fan QH,Chen ZJ,et al.Influence study of lower limb robot-assisted gait training on rehabilitation effects and quality of life of children patients with cerebral palsy[J].Chin Med Equipment,2020,17(11):94-97.(in Chinese)
[18] 杨艳.下肢康复机器人对脑性瘫痪儿童步行功能的影响[J].心理医生,2016,22(3):219-220.
Yang Y.Effect of lower limb rehabilitation robot on walking function of children with cerebral palsy[J].The Psychologist,2016,22(3):219-220.(in Chinese)
[19] 马婷婷,张皓.机器人辅助步态训练对痉挛型脑性瘫痪患儿运动和步行功能的效果[J].中国康复理论与实践,2021,27(11):1260-1265.
Ma TT,Zhang H.Effect of robotic-assisted gait training on motor and walking for children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Chin J Rehabil Theory Pract,2021,27(11):1260-1265.(in Chinese)
[20] 张瑞娟.康复机器人辅助步行训练对脑瘫患儿下肢肌张力及平衡能力的影响[J].中国实用医刊,2018,45(13):3.
Zhang RJ.Effects of rehabilitation robot-assisted walking training on lower limb muscle tone and balance in children with cerebral palsy[J].Chin J Pract Med,2018,45(13):3.(in Chinese)
[21] 吕楠,尚清,马彩云,等.康复机器人对痉挛型脑性瘫痪患儿的康复效果[J].中国实用神经疾病杂志,2017,20(7):45-47.
Lyu N,Shang Q,Ma CY,et al.Rehabilitation effect of rehabilitation robot on children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Chin J Pract Nerv Dis,2017,20(7):45-47.(in Chinese)
[22] 顾术理,赵洋洋,张倩倩,等.悬吊运动训练对痉挛型脑性瘫痪患儿粗大运动功能、平衡功能及肌电图的影响[J].中国中西医结合儿科学,2022,14(1):45-48.
Gu SL,Zhao YY,Zhang QQ,et al.Effects of suspension exercise training on gross motor function, balance function and electromyography in children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Chin Pediatr Integr Tradit West Med,2022,14(1):45-48.(in Chinese)
[23] 郭培坚,彭桂兰.悬吊训练结合肌内效贴对痉挛型脑瘫患儿步行和平衡能力的影响[J].中外医疗,2020,39(7):48-51.
Guo PJ,Peng GL.Effects of suspension training combined with intramuscular patch on walking and balance in children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].China Foreign Med Treat,2020,39(7):48-51.(in Chinese)
[24] 康贝贝,徐磊,卢明甲,等.儿童悬吊训练系统对脑瘫儿童躯干控制及粗大运动功能的影响[J].中国儿童保健杂志,2017,25(9):891-893.
Kang BB,Xu L,Lu MJ,et al.Effect of children′s sling exercise training system on trunk control and gross motor functionin children with cerebral palsy[J].Chin J Child Health Care,2017,25(9):891-893.(in Chinese)
[25] 金国圣,丁洁,侯梅,等.悬吊训练对痉挛型脑瘫患儿核心稳定性的影响[J].中国儿童保健杂志,2020,28(3):349-351,354.
Jin GS,Ding J,Hou M,et al.Effect of sling exercise training on core stability of children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Chin J Child Health Care,2020,28(3):349-351,354.(in Chinese)
[26] 赵梦霞,刘款,宋桢桢,等.悬吊运动锻炼对痉挛型脑性瘫痪患儿康复效果的影响[J].中国中西医结合儿科学,2020,12(4):320-323.
Zhao MX,Liu K,Song ZZ,et al.Effect of suspension exercise on rehabilitation of children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Chin Pediatr Integr Tradit West Med,2020,12(4):320-323.(in Chinese)
[27] 张莉莉,刘一苇,叶常州,等.悬吊运动训练结合家庭姿势管理对痉挛型脑瘫儿童粗大运动功能,平衡功能和日常生活活动能力的影响[J].中华物理医学与康复杂志,2021,43(10):3.
Zhang L,Liu YW,Ye CZ,et al.Effects of suspension exercise training combined with family postural management on gross motor function, balance function and activities of daily living in children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Chin J Phys Med and Rehabil,2021,43(10):3.(in Chinese)
[28] 王军,郎永斌,杜江华,等.悬吊运动训练对痉挛型脑瘫患儿运动及平衡功能的影响[J].中国当代儿科杂志,2018,20(6):465-469.
Wang J,Lang YB,Du JH,et al.Effect of suspension exercise training on motor and balance functions in children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Chin J Contemp Pediatr,2018,20(6):465-469.(in Chinese)
[29] 张红霞,刘正阳,刘尉叶.任务导向性训练对痉挛型脑瘫患儿运动功能及肌张力的影响[J].中国疗养医学,2021,30(9):968-970.
Zhang HX,Liu ZY,Liu WY.Effects of task-oriented training on motor function and muscle tone in children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Chin J Convalescent Med,2021,30(9):968-970.(in Chinese)
[30] 张春阳,庞伟,范艳萍,等.任务导向性训练对痉挛型脑性瘫痪儿童的平衡控制影响[J].中国中西医结合儿科学,2014,6(2):164-166.
Zhang CY,Pang W,Fan YP,et al.Effect of task-oriented training on balance control in children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Chin Pediatr Integr Tradit West Med,2014,6(2):164-166.(in Chinese)
[31] 李鑫,庞伟,范艳萍,等.任务导向性训练对痉挛型脑瘫患儿移动功能疗效研究[J].中国儿童保健杂志,2015,23(5):556-558.
Li X,Pang W,Fan YP,et al.Effects of task-oriented training method as a rehabilitation strategy for mobile motor function of spastic cerebral palsy children[J].Chin J Child Health Care,2015,23(5):556-558.(in Chinese)
[32] 庞伟,李鑫,范艳萍,等.任务导向性训练对痉挛型脑性瘫痪儿童粗大运动功能及步行功能的疗效[J].中国康复医学杂志,2016,31(1):30-34.
Pang W,Li X,Fan YP,et al.Effects of task oriented training method as a rehabilitation strategy for gross motor and gait function of spastic cerebral palsy children[J].Chin J Rehabil Med,2016,31(1):30-34.(in Chinese)
[33] Sah AK,Balaji GK,Agrahara S.Effects of task-oriented activities based on neurodevelopmental therapy principles on trunk control,balance,and gross motor function in children with spastic diplegic cerebral palsy: A single-blinded randomized clinical trial[J].J Pediatr Neurosci,2019,14(3):120-126.
[34] 毛正欢,王慧,尹宏伟,等.任务导向性训练联合水疗对痉挛型脑瘫患儿运动功能的影响[J].浙江中西医结合杂志,2022,32(3):248-252.
Mao ZH,Wang H,Yin HW,et al.Effect of task-oriented training combined with hydrotherapy on motor function of children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Zhejiang J Integr Tradit Chin West Med,2022,32(3):248-252.(in Chinese)
[35] 任凯,龚晓明,章荣,等.虚拟现实训练对痉挛型脑瘫患儿粗大运动功能及步行速度的影响[J].中国妇幼保健,2016,31(15):3047-3049.
Ren K,Gong XM,Zhang R,et al.Effect of virtual reality training on gross motor function and walking speed of children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Matern Child Health Care China,2016,31(15):3047-3049.(in Chinese)
[36] 王亚莉,马小琴,安慧,等.基于虚拟现实技术的康复训练对痉挛型脑瘫患儿平衡功能和粗大运动功能的影响[J].中国护理管理,2020,20(12):1898-1902.
Wang YL,Ma XQ,An H,et al.Effect of virtual reality technology on balance function and gross motor function in children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Chin Nurs Manage,2020,20(12):1898-1902.(in Chinese)
[37] 杨美霞,张玮涛,傅建明,等.虚拟现实训练技术对痉挛型脑瘫患儿平衡功能的影响[J].中华物理医学与康复杂志,2019,41(4):3.
Yang MX,Zhang WT,Fu JM,et al.Effect of virtual reality training technology on balance function in children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Chin J Phys Med Rehabil,2019,41(4):3.(in Chinese)
[38] 高晶,王丽娜,赵斌.虚拟情景循环踏车训练对痉挛型脑瘫患儿下肢肌张力及运动功能的影响[J].中华物理医学与康复杂志,2015,37(6):4.
Gao J,Wang LN,Zhao B.Stationary cycle training for improving lower limb muscle tension and motor function in children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Chin J Phys Med Rehabil,2015,37(6):4.(in Chinese)
[39] 徐怡,赵晓科,陈梦莹,等.虚拟现实技术缓解痉挛型脑性瘫痪患儿治疗性疼痛的效果[J].中国康复理论与实践,2019,25(12):1458-1462.
Xu Y,Zhao XK,Chen MY,et al.Effect of virtual reality on therapeutic pain in children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Chin J Rehabil Theory Pract,2019,25(12):1458-1462.(in Chinese)
[40] Jha KK,Karunanithi GB,Sahana A,et al.Randomised trial of virtual reality gaming and physiotherapy on balance, gross motor performance and daily functions among children with bilateral spastic cerebral palsy[J].Somatosens Mot Res,2021,38(2):117-126.
[41] 蔡文丽,何强勇,陈小芳,等.全身振动疗法对痉挛型双瘫粗大运动功能与平衡功能的影响[J].按摩与康复医学,2018,9(15):8-9.
Cai WL,He QY,Chen XF,et al.Effect of whole body vibration therapy on gross motor function and balance function in patients with spastic diplegia[J].Chin Manipul Rehabil Med,2018,9(15):8-9.(in Chinese)
[42] 严善钟,金娟,陈世动,等.全身振动训练对痉挛型脑瘫患儿 20 例步行速度及粗大运动功能影响研究[J].中国实用儿科杂志,2021,36(1):33-37.
Yan SZ,Jin J,Chen SD,et al.Effect of whole body vibration on gait speed and gross motor function of pediatric patients with spastic cerebral palsy: A study of 20 cases[J].Chin J Pract Pediatr,2021,36(1):33-37.(in Chinese)
[43] 孟文彬,刘锋伟,董婵,等.全身振动训练对1～3岁痉挛型脑瘫患儿下肢运动功能的影响[J].郑州大学学报(医学版),2017,52(6):740-745.
Meng WB,Liu FW,Dong C,et al.Effects of whole body vibration training on lower limb motor function in children aged 1～3 years with spastic cerebral palsy[J].J Zhengzhou Univ Med Sci,2017,52(6):740-745.(in Chinese)
[44] 尹宏伟,李海峰,张鑫,等.全身振动疗法对痉挛型双瘫患儿下肢运动功能的影响[J].中华物理医学与康复杂志,2019,41(10):752-756.
Yin HW,Li HF,Zhang X,et al.Effect of whole body vibration therapy on lower limb motor function in children with spastic diplegia[J].Chin J Phys Med Rehabil,2019,41(10):752-756.(in Chinese)
[45] Ibrahim MM,Eid MA,Moawd SA.Effect of whole-body vibration on muscle strength, spasticity, and motor performance in spastic diplegic cerebral palsy children[J].Egypt J Med Hum Genet,2014,15(2):173-179.
[46] 张丽华,郄淑燕,张黎明,等.重复经颅磁刺激对痉挛型脑瘫患儿痉挛及运动功能的影响[J].中国康复,2015,30(3):171-173.
Zhang LH,Qie SY,Zhang LM,et al.Effects of repeated transcranial magnetic stimulation on spasm and motor function in children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Chin J Rehabil,2015,30(3):171-173.(in Chinese)
[47] 武改,鲍克秀,李之林,等.重复经颅磁刺激对痉挛型脑瘫患儿语言发育能力及运动功能的影响[J].现代生物医学进展,2017,17(29):5716-5719,5772.
Wu G,Bao KX,Li ZL,et al.Effects of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation on language development and motor function in children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Progr Modern Biomed,2017,17(29):5716-5719,5772.(in Chinese)
[48] 李新剑,仇爱珍,金鑫,等.重复经颅磁刺激联合康复训练治疗对促进脑瘫患儿运动功能发育与智力提高的作用[J].中国实用神经疾病杂志,2015,18(23):17-19.
Li XJ,Qiu AZ,Jin X,et al.Effect of improvement of intellect and motor function of children with cerebral palsy treated by repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation combined with rehabilitation training[J].Chin J Pract Nerv Dis,2015,18(23):17-19.(in Chinese)
[49] 梁玉.重复经颅磁刺激对痉挛偏瘫型脑瘫患儿平衡功能恢复的影响[J].黑龙江医药科学,2020,43(4):160-162.
Liang Y.Effects of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation on the recovery of balance function in children with spastic hemiplegic cerebral palsy[J].Heilongjiang Med and Pharm,2020,43(4):160-162.(in Chinese)
[50] Saquetto M,Carvalho V,Silva C,et al.The effects of whole body vibration on mobility and balance in children with cerebral palsy: A systematic review with meta-analysis[J].J Musculoskelet Neuronal Interact,2015,15(2):137-144.
[51] 熊友红,何小辉,唐巧萍,等.MOTOmed智能训练结合水疗改善痉挛型脑瘫患儿步行能力的临床研究[J].中国康复医学杂志,2014,29(5):481-482.
Xiong YH,He XH,Tang QP,et al.Clinical study on MOTOmed intelligent training combined with hydrotherapy to improve the walking ability of children with spastic cerebral palsy[J].Chin J Rehabil Med,2014,29(5):481-482.(in Chinese)